Saturday, May 29, 2021

Chapter 2 - Dinner with the Sub-warden

Pt. 1 - Mark Studdock has dinner with Curry, the bursar, and Dick Devine. After Curry & the bursar have to leave, he continues his conversation with Devine and learns a little more about the nature & eventual goals of N.I.C.E. Devine extends possible invitation to join the organization.

Pt. 2 - Mark comes home to find Jane an emotional wreck. He is utterly unable to help her or even comprehend the problem.

Pt. 3 - The next morning over breakfast, Mark & Jane have an argument, neither able to address what is really frustrating them. The chapter ends with Mark leaving to meet the director of N.I.C.E. and Jane leaving to meet Dr. Dimble’s friend, Miss Ironwood.


So the chapters in this book are reliably about 20 pages. Does one chapter a week sound good to everyone here? Should we go faster? Slow down?

Wednesday, May 26, 2021

Out of the Silent Planet - book 1 of The Space Trilogy

Our current selection is the final book of a trilogy. It works fine on its own, but does occasionally refer back to previous events. It seems only fair, then, to take a couple of midweek posts to describe books 1 & 2.



The book starts off with Elwin Ransom, a college professor on break. While on a walking tour, he meets Dr. Weston & Dick Devine (Lord Feverstone by book 3). The two kidnap him to another planet via Weston’s spaceship. He escapes them shortly after their arrival on Malacandra (the local name), and, after wandering alone a while, meets and befriends a native named Hyoi.

Spoilers until the line break

Ransom lives with Hyoi and his people (the Hrossa) for some weeks and learns their ways. He also learns that they know of his world, and say that it is cut off from the rest of the solar system, ruled by an inhuman intelligence that rebelled against its maker.

While Ransom is out hunting with the Hrossa, his friend Hyoi is killed by a rifle shot from Weston & Devine. An eldil (an angel) tells Ransom that he must go see the Oyarsa, the ruler of all Malacandrans.

Ransom journeys across Malacandra, seeing regions of the alien world greatly different from what he has known so far. He meets another species of rational Malacandran, the pale giants called Sorns.

Finally, he reaches the valley of the Oyarsa and meets the being, whom he cannot clearly see. He recounts his time on Malacandra, and humbly apologizes for his failing to come much earlier, which he should have.

Dr. Weston and Devine are brought captive before the Oyarsa. Not believing in the unseen, they think this is all some kind of trick, and alternately attempt to bribe and intimidate the Malacandrans. This mostly confuses and amuses the audience. Finally, the Oyarsa demands an accounting of their actions. Devine is apparently merely greedy for gold. Weston, however, has a vision of humanity colonizing Malacandra, killing the natives if necessary, then leaping from world to world, escaping extinction until the death of the universe.

The Oyarsa pronounces them both corrupt, Devine weakly so, and Weston profoundly so. He decrees they must depart immediately. They make the return journey, barely reaching Earth before their air runs out.

END SPOILERS


This book is the least explicitly Christian of the three. If you know what you're looking for, it's quite clear, but it would be entirely possible to read this book without being aware of its connection to Christianity in specific. It is unavoidably a philosophical and moral book, but without specifically Christian references, a bit like The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe.

It's a bit interesting as an s.f. fan to look at it as an example of early 20th century s.f. The most interesting part to me is his description of interplanetary space as not empty and bleak, but full of life and vitality. Also, he gets it right that the Earth's gravity would no longer affect the occupants of the ship, but doesn't realize that the ship's acceleration would take its place. Thus, he has them affected only by gravity of the ship itself, which, in reality, would be almost unnoticeable.

Another part I found particularly well-done was Ransom's brief mental breakdown upon finding himself alone on an alien planet. It is fascinating and frightening without being too creepy or explicit.

This isn't my favorite C.S. Lewis book. It's not even my favorite of this trilogy. But it's worth a read.

Saturday, May 22, 2021

Chapter 1 - Sale of College Property

 Part 1 - Jane Studdock mopes around her & her husband's home by herself, feeling frustrated and undirected. A picture she sees in a newspaper reminds her of a horrifying dream she had which involved one man's head being taken off and another man apparently being revived from the dead.

Part 2 - Mark Studdock (Jane's husband) is on the way to a meeting of Bracton College, of which he is a fellow. We learn a little bit of the history of the college, and of the office politics which run the place. Mark is excited to find himself apparently being subtly invited into the "progressive element."

Part 3 - We are given a short description of Bragdon Wood and its history and legends, including Merlin's Well, under which the great wizard himself is supposed to be buried, neither dead nor alive.

Part 4 - The Fellows of Bracton College hold a faculty meeting, through much careful manipulation & maneuvering, the progressive element manage to get the sale of Bracton Wood to N.I.C.E. passed, which idea would have been greeted with horror by the more traditional elements of the school.

Part 5 - Jane is invited to the home of Dr. & Mrs. Dimble. She discusses some of her marriage troubles with Mrs. Dimble. Dr. Dimble talks about Arthurian legend and Merlin. Something in the discussion reminds Jane once again of her terrible dream, and she tells the Dimbles all about it. Dr. Dimble appears to take her dream quite seriously, and offers her someone to talk with about it.


I am currently planning to cover about a chapter a week. I doubt this will be too much for any of you. If, however, it proves to be too slow, we'll consider two chapters.

I look forward to your thoughts.

Friday, May 14, 2021

We will shortly be starting our new book That Hideous Strength

I have to start with an apology. I find "The Power of the Powerless" very interesting and tremendously relevant to the current gaslighting culture. I also find it extremely dense and requiring serious concentration of a type I find it difficult to muster for long periods under current circumstances. This makes it difficult to maintain a regular schedule for discussion. Sorry about that.

Having said that, I plan on us starting C.S. Lewis's novel That Hideous Strength. If you're interested, the discussion post on chapter one will be up next Saturday, May 22nd. I hope you join us.

I have few worries about being able to maintain a good pace with this book.

God be with you.


UPDATE: I am having trouble getting the Disqus comments section to load. If you do not see it, try loading this page in a different browser or in private/incognito mode.


Tuesday, April 13, 2021

The Power of the Powerless parts VIII - X

Part VIII - Post-totalitarian systems impose a false, anti-human way of life on their subjects. Refusal to play along with the lie is a constant threat to their power. Simple refusal to speak the lie is a form of power and inevitably creates a formidable opposition.

Part IX - We need a higher cause than mere survival and material prosperity. Loyalty to the truth can be that cause. It may not produce immediate payoffs, but it will, by its nature, create resistance to post-totalitarianism.

Part X - In a post-totalitarian system, there is no such thing as non-political activity. Those who depend on lies must fear (and thus must attack) dissent from any possible angle. Nothing can be left alone to be enjoyed for its own sake because there is no telling where dissent may suddenly pop up.


Sorry for posting this late (and short), guys. I can only plead that we're still getting moved in and set up and it's consuming more time and energy than I had anticipated. Hopefully, we'll have everything back to normal soon. I'll try to get through part XIV for the next post.

Sunday, April 4, 2021

The Power of the Powerless parts I - VII

First of all, Happy Easter, and he is risen!

Second, let’s go ahead and get started discussing Havel’s extended essay.

The Power of the Powerless

Part I - There is a thread of dissent running through Eastern Europe. Who are these dissidents? What is the system they rebel against? What form does their dissent take?

Part II - The system Havel contends with is not a dictatorship as traditionally understood, although it may have started out that way. Dictatorships are run strictly by force, and are, in a fashion, disconnected from the tradition and the larger culture. What Havel faces is something else, which he calls post-totalitarian.

Part III - Havel gives the example of a small greengrocer who posts in his shop the sign “workers of the world unite.” What does he mean by this? What is the real import of that sign? How is his posting of that sign a part of the post-totalitarian system?

Part IV - What is the essence of the post-totalitarian system? When and how does it affect those living under it?

Part V - The post-totalitarian system is driven by an ideology which seems to take on a life of its own. Even those seemingly in power must follow the demands of the ideology, and can be quickly destroyed if they step out of line.

Part VI - Why does the system demand a repeating of its mantras? Why must everyone, regardless of acting in line with its demands, also mouth its lies? Everyone in such a system, down to the lowest level, is complicit in its evil because every act of compliance and compromise reinforces it.

Part VII - What happens to those who refuse to comply? How does such refusal threaten the post-totalitarian system?


For next week, we'll read through part XII, page 37 on my copy. I look forward to your thoughts.

Wednesday, March 31, 2021

The dissident and the powerless

Okay, current plan: the discussion thread for our first section of "The Power of the Powerless" will go up on Saturday morning. For this section, we'll be covering parts I-VII. In the PDF I linked to, that goes up through page 20. Once we've completed "The Power of the Powerless" (which looks like it'll take about a month), we'll start C.S. Lewis's That Hideous Strength. I look forward to hearing your thoughts.